Opal vs Moonstone: Differences, Benefits, and How to Choose the Right Gemstone

March 13, 2025

Q1: Which is better, opal or moonstone?

Both opal and moonstone are beautiful gemstones with unique qualities, making them popular choices for jewelry. Opal is prized for its vibrant play-of-color, which creates a stunning rainbow effect under light. It's ideal for those seeking a bold, eye-catching piece. On the other hand, moonstone is known for its soft, glowing adularescence, giving it a mystical, calming appearance. If you prefer vibrant color flashes, opal might be the better choice; if you prefer a more subtle and calming glow, moonstone could be ideal.

Q2: Is opal more expensive than moonstone?

Yes, opals are generally more expensive than moonstones due to their rarity and unique play-of-color. High-quality black opals from Australia, for example, can cost thousands of dollars per carat. In contrast, moonstones are more affordable, with most high-quality pieces priced between $20 and $200 per carat, depending on clarity and color. However, rare moonstones with intense blue sheen can be priced higher.

Q3: How to tell a moonstone from an opal?

To distinguish between a moonstone and an opal, observe their optical effects and overall appearance:

Opal: Displays a vibrant play-of-color with flashes of red, green, blue, and purple. It has a slightly waxy or glassy surface.
Moonstone: Exhibits adularescence—a soft, glowing light that moves across the surface as the stone is tilted. Moonstone often has a milky or translucent body color.

If you're unsure, a professional gemologist can confirm the gemstone type using specialized equipment.

Q4: Who should not wear opal or moonstone?

According to some metaphysical beliefs and astrology:

Opal: It's said that opals may not be suitable for individuals with dominant Mars or Sun signs, such as Aries, Leo, and Scorpio. Opal’s water-based energy might conflict with these fire signs, leading to emotional imbalance.
Moonstone: Moonstone is linked to lunar energy and emotional sensitivity. Those prone to emotional instability or mood swings may find moonstone’s amplifying effect overwhelming.

However, personal preference and comfort should guide your choice when wearing these gemstones.

Q5: Can I wear opal and moonstone together?

Yes, opal and moonstone can be worn together, but it depends on your intention and energy alignment. Opal represents emotional intensity and creativity, while moonstone symbolizes calmness and balance. Wearing them together may create a harmonious balance between passion and tranquility. However, if you find their combined energy overwhelming, you might prefer wearing them separately.

Q6: What is the negative impact of opal and moonstone?

While opal and moonstone are believed to have positive properties, they also have potential downsides:

Opal:
- Emotional Sensitivity: Opal's strong energy may heighten emotional sensitivity and anxiety.
- Fragility: Opal has a Mohs hardness of 5.5 - 6.5, making it prone to scratches and cracks.
- Water Content: Opals contain water and may crack or lose their play-of-color if exposed to dry or hot environments.
- Astrological Conflict: Opal’s water-based energy may conflict with fire signs, causing emotional imbalance.
Moonstone:
- Brittle Nature: Moonstone has a Mohs hardness of 6 - 6.5, making it susceptible to chipping or cracking.
- Emotional Amplification: Moonstone’s energy can heighten emotional sensitivity, which may cause mood swings.
- Over-Reliance: Wearing moonstone for emotional balance might create dependency on its energy.
- Loss of Sheen: Prolonged exposure to strong light or chemicals may reduce the moonstone’s adularescence.

To maintain their beauty and energy, store opals and moonstones separately and handle them with care.

Q7: What are the benefits of wearing opal and moonstone?

Both opal and moonstone have long been associated with metaphysical and emotional benefits:

Opal:
- Creativity and Inspiration: Opal is believed to enhance creativity and spark new ideas.
- Emotional Healing: Opal is thought to release emotional blockages and promote inner peace.
- Confidence: Wearing opal may boost self-confidence and personal expression.
Moonstone:
- Emotional Balance: Moonstone is said to calm the mind and stabilize emotions.
- Feminine Energy: Associated with the moon and goddess energy, moonstone is linked to intuition and inner strength.
- Good Fortune: Moonstone is considered a stone of luck and new beginnings.

Both stones can complement each other by balancing emotional intensity with calmness.

Q8: Can opal and moonstone be worn every day?

While both stones can be worn daily, they require care due to their softness and fragility:

Opal: With a Mohs hardness of 5.5 - 6.5, opal is prone to scratches and should be worn with caution. Avoid exposure to heat and chemicals.
Moonstone: Moonstone’s Mohs hardness of 6 - 6.5 makes it slightly more durable than opal, but it can still chip or crack if struck. Keep it away from harsh chemicals and store it separately from harder stones.

If you choose to wear them daily, consider protective settings like bezel settings to reduce the risk of damage.

Q9: How should opal and moonstone be cleaned and maintained?

To preserve the beauty of your opal and moonstone jewelry:

Opal:
- Clean with mild soapy water and a soft cloth.
- Avoid ultrasonic and steam cleaning as they may damage the stone.
- Store opals away from heat and sunlight to prevent drying and cracking.
Moonstone:
- Use lukewarm water and a soft cloth to clean moonstone.
- Avoid harsh chemicals and strong sunlight to maintain its sheen.
- Store moonstones in a soft pouch to prevent scratches.

Proper care will help maintain the luster and integrity of both stones for years to come.

Q10: Are opal and moonstone birthstones?

Yes, both opal and moonstone are recognized birthstones:

Opal: Opal is the traditional birthstone for October, symbolizing hope, creativity, and emotional balance.
Moonstone: Moonstone is the modern birthstone for June, representing intuition, calmness, and new beginnings.

Wearing your birthstone is believed to enhance your connection with its energy and bring positive influences into your life.

Back to blog